Skylight repair in Brooklyn

A brown ring spreading on the stairwell ceiling, a dome that finally cracked, or plywood somebody screwed over the opening years ago because nobody could find the leak. We are a Brooklyn company, based on Gerritsen Avenue, and we have been repairing skylights across this borough since 2005. Most of the time the skylight itself is not what failed. The assessment is free and an active leak goes to the front of the schedule.

Patch it or replace it, the honest numbers. Patching a leaking skylight in Brooklyn, meaning a reflash, a reseal or a curb patch, runs $650 to $1,800, and nobody can honestly guarantee a patch, so we do not. A new skylight set on your existing curb starts at $2,287 installed and carries our 10 Year No Leak Warranty and 5 Year Labor Warranty. On most Brooklyn roofs the gap between those two numbers is a few hundred dollars, which is why we usually recommend the replacement. We tell you which one your roof needs at the free assessment, and when a patch is the right call we say so.

Find out what is failing before you call anyone. Our leak diagnostic asks six questions about where the water shows and what the glass looks like, then names the likely cause and the four photos that get it priced properly.

Leaking right now? We are in Brooklyn, not coming in from somewhere else

If water is coming in today, call (718) 646-7053. Phones are answered evenings and weekends and an active leak is flagged the same day. Our shop is at 2728 Gerritsen Avenue, which means a Brooklyn job is a short drive and not a trip in from another county with a travel charge on the end of it.

Skylights are the only thing we do. A roofer who touches a skylight twice a year will tar around the problem and call back in April. We have been doing this since 2005, we are an official VELUX dealer and a VELUX Trained and Approved installer, and we are licensed and insured, LIC# 2084179.

The brownstone stair skylight, and the laylight hanging under it

From Park Slope through Fort Greene, Clinton Hill, Bedford Stuyvesant and Crown Heights, the original skylight sits at the top of the stair with a decorative laylight hanging below it. They are a pair, and most owners forget the laylight is up there until plaster starts coming down on the top landing.

These weather units are usually single glazed, painted shut, and running on putty that gave up decades ago. We replace the unit above with insulated glass and leave the laylight where it is worth keeping, which on an original interior it almost always is.

The shaft between the two matters as much as the glass. A shaft that was never insulated will stream with condensation in January and look exactly like a leak. We check that before quoting anything. Real figures for this work are on the brownstone skylight page.

Flat and low slope roofs, and what the re-coat covered up

Most of Brooklyn is flat or close to it, so the unit belongs on a built curb and flashed into the membrane. A deck mounted unit, the kind made for a shingle roof, does not belong on a flat roof and will leak eventually no matter who set it.

When the water starts, the curb is the usual answer. It is wood, it is thirty or forty years old, and every roofer who came through coated around it instead of rebuilding it. After the curb comes the counterflashing where the roof turns up into the parapet, then the seals on the unit, and only last the glass.

If the roof was coated or replaced since the skylight went in, the coating almost always ran straight over the base flashing. It looks tidy and it holds water against the curb. How we price that work is on the flat roof skylight page, and the full walk-through is on skylight leak repair.

Cracked acrylic domes on rotted curbs, all over south Brooklyn

Marine Park, Gerritsen Beach, Mill Basin, Bergen Beach, Sheepshead Bay, Dyker Heights and Bay Ridge are full of bubble domes that went on in the seventies and eighties. The acrylic yellows, hazes, goes brittle and finally splits, usually along a corner.

Swapping the dome alone is sometimes the right call and we will say so. But a dome that cracked on a twenty year old curb is normally sitting on wood that is soft at the corners, and new plastic on a bad curb is leaking again inside a season. We open the corners and look before we quote.

We install both acrylic and glass and we will tell you honestly why we steer toward glass. Acrylic yellows and hazes, glass stays clear, it is quieter under heavy rain, it insulates better and it carries a factory seal warranty. If you want the dome, we will sell you the dome. The comparison is on our acrylic dome page.

The skylight somebody boarded over

There is a version of this job in every Brooklyn neighborhood. The stair skylight leaked, nobody could find where, so it got covered with plywood and roofing cement and the top floor has been dark ever since. Sometimes it was tarred flat and you can only find it from the roof.

That opening is almost always worth reopening. The curb underneath is the real problem in nearly every case, and once it is rebuilt and flashed properly a glass unit goes on it and the stair gets its daylight back. In a row house with windows on two walls only, that stair skylight is the only daylight the middle of the house ever gets.

Co-op and condo buildings, and the loft conversions

In Brooklyn Heights, Downtown Brooklyn, Williamsburg and Greenpoint the skylight is usually over a common element. The stair bulkhead, the light shaft, the hallway at the top of the line. That makes the roof the building, not the apartment, and the job needs the board before it needs a crew.

Five things get the managing agent moving instead of stalling: a certificate of insurance naming the building, the managing agent and the board as additional insureds, our license number, a written scope saying exactly what is being opened and closed, the product data sheet, and a schedule the super can live with. We hand all five over without being chased. Detail is on our page for boards and managing agents.

Landmark districts and what counts as like for like

Brooklyn Heights, Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens, Park Slope, Fort Greene, Clinton Hill, Boerum Hill, Crown Heights North, DUMBO and Ditmas Park are all landmarked in whole or in part, and the question that decides everything is whether the skylight can be seen from the street.

A replacement on a rear slope or set back behind a parapet is a very different conversation from anything on a visible front roof. Like for like replacement is the easiest path and it is often available. Change the size, the profile or the sightline and it becomes a different application. We will tell you which one you are in before you spend money on drawings. The detail is on our NYC permits and landmark rules page.

Wire glass and steel frames on the industrial blocks

Gowanus, Red Hook, Sunset Park, Bushwick, East Williamsburg and the Navy Yard still carry hundreds of galvanized steel skylights with wire glass in them, over stair bulkheads, factory floors and warehouse space. The steel rusts from inside the glazing pocket and the putty turns to dust.

Wire glass is the old safety standard and it is not what a current sloped glazing build uses. A replacement wants laminated glass in the inboard lite so nothing can come down into the space below. We replace these units and we fabricate custom frames where the opening is not a stock size. See wire glass skylight replacement.

What we actually repair, and what each one involves

People call about a leak and describe the glass. The glass is almost never the problem. Here is the whole list of what we get called out for in Brooklyn and what the work is in each case.

Flashing and curb rebuilds. The curb is the wood box the skylight sits on and the flashing is the metal that ties it into the roof. Water that shows up at the ceiling has nearly always come in at that joint, run along a rafter and dropped somewhere else. We open the corners, find how far the rot went, rebuild the curb square and re-flash it into the roof surface that is actually up there. More on a skylight that keeps leaking after it was repaired.

Resealing, when a reseal is honest. There are two seals and people mix them up. The perimeter seal between the unit and the curb can be redone and it holds. The seal between the panes of glass cannot be redone at all. We tell you which one failed before anybody spends money. More on resealing a skylight.

Failed glass units. Water sitting between the panes, or a haze that does not wipe off, means the glass seal is gone. On most units the glass is bonded into the frame at the factory, so what gets replaced is the unit and not the pane. The data plate tells us whether yours is one of the exceptions. More on replacing skylight glass.

Cracked and chalked acrylic domes. Common right across south Brooklyn. A dome that split on a twenty year old curb is usually sitting on wood that has gone soft at the corners, and new plastic on a bad curb leaks again inside a season. We open the corners first, then quote either a new dome or a glass unit on a rebuilt curb. More on acrylic domes.

Wire glass in galvanized steel frames. The industrial blocks and the loft conversions are full of these. The steel is usually still sound and it is the glazing and the putty that have finished. Wire glass was never safety glass. We reglaze them where the frame allows it and replace the assembly where it does not. More on wire glass and steel skylights.

Electric and solar units that stopped opening. On a solar unit the battery goes long before the motor does, a rain sensor doing its job looks like a fault, and a remote can simply lose its pairing. We work out which of the three you have before anybody orders a motor. More on a skylight that will not open.

Condensation that gets reported as a leak. It starts in October and it looks exactly like a leak. Water on the underside of the glass on a cold morning is almost always condensation, and the fix for it is not sealant. More on telling condensation from a leak.

Openings somebody boarded over. Boarding over is what gets done when a leak cannot be found. The curb underneath is the real fault in almost every case, so the opening can be rebuilt and glazed and the middle of the house gets its daylight back.

The one thing none of this can be done from is a photo. The corners have to be opened to see how far the rot went, which is why the assessment is free and why we will not read you a repair price over the phone. Start with the diagnostic if you want to narrow it down before we come out.

What it costs, and what we will not guess at

A repair gets priced after somebody looks at it, because the gap between re-flashing a sound curb and rebuilding a rotted one is most of the bill. What we can publish honestly is the replacement side. On an existing sound curb, a skylight replacement starts at $2,287 installed, with $1,760 standard replacement labor. Cutting a brand new opening starts at $3,850 installed, because the framing, the flashing and the interior finish are all part of it.

Every number we publish is on the pricing page and none of them are teasers. If the measure turns up rot or a structural header beyond ordinary framing, that is priced separately and you approve it before we touch it.

Common questions about skylight repair in Brooklyn

Who repairs skylights in Brooklyn?

New York Skylight Installers, (718) 646-7053, based at 2728 Gerritsen Avenue in Brooklyn. Skylight specialists since 2005 and skylights are the only thing we do. A general roofer patches around a skylight; a skylight company finds what actually failed. The assessment is free.

Are you actually based in Brooklyn or do you just advertise here?

Our shop is on Gerritsen Avenue in Marine Park. That is why a Brooklyn call does not carry a travel charge and why an active leak in this borough can usually be seen the same day.

Somebody boarded over my stair skylight years ago. Is it worth reopening?

Nearly always. Boarding over is what gets done when a leak cannot be found, and the curb underneath is the real fault in almost every case. Rebuild the curb, flash it properly, set a glass unit on it, and the middle of the house gets daylight back.

My dome cracked. Can you just drop a new dome on it?

Sometimes, and we will say so when it is true. But a dome that split on a twenty year old curb is usually sitting on wood that is soft at the corners, and new plastic on a bad curb leaks again within a season. We open the corners and look before quoting the dome.

My roof was coated two years ago and the skylight leaks worse now. Why?

Because the coating almost certainly ran over the base flashing instead of stopping short of it. It looks neat from across the roof and it traps water against the curb, so the wood rots faster than it did before the coating went on.

Do I need Landmarks approval to replace a skylight in Park Slope or Brooklyn Heights?

It depends on whether the unit is visible from the street. A rear slope or anything set behind a parapet is treated very differently from a visible front roof, and like for like replacement is often available. We tell you which one you are in before you spend money on drawings.

What kinds of skylight repair do you do in Brooklyn?

Flashing and curb rebuilds, perimeter reseals where a reseal will actually hold, failed glass units, cracked acrylic domes, wire glass in galvanized steel frames, electric and solar units that have stopped opening, condensation that gets reported as a leak, and openings somebody boarded over years ago. Skylights are the only thing we do, so all of it is in house. The assessment is free.

Do you repair the skylight or do you always want to replace it?

We patch it when a patch is the right call, and we tell you when it is not. A patch runs $650 to $1,800 and carries no guarantee, because nobody can honestly guarantee a reflash on an old curb. A new skylight on the existing curb starts at $2,287 installed with a 10 Year No Leak Warranty. When the two numbers are that close, the replacement is the smarter spend, and we would rather say that at the assessment than come back in April.

Can you supply the skylight if my own roofer is doing the work?

Yes. We sell units, flashing kits and curbs supply only to Brooklyn roofers, general contractors and owners doing their own work. Details are on our trade page.

We work the whole borough. Brooklyn skylight installation · Park Slope · Brooklyn Heights · Bedford Stuyvesant · Crown Heights · Fort Greene & Clinton Hill · Carroll Gardens & Cobble Hill · Boerum Hill · Prospect Heights · Windsor Terrace · Prospect Lefferts Gardens · Ditmas Park · Bay Ridge · Sunset Park · Williamsburg · Greenpoint · Bushwick. Repairs in Manhattan, Queens, the Bronx and Staten Island too.